Ignore Chuck Todd’s ‘Help:’ Six Journalists Lester Holt Should Emulate

Holt isn’t going to master the fine balance between equity and a quest for the truth by studying Todd.

NBC’s Lester Holt was a huge part of my formative news years. From the mid-1980s until 2000, Holt was the lead anchor on Chicago’s CBS affiliate, a reliable, just-the-facts professional with his finger on the pulse of Windy City issues. Though he’s since divested himself of then-signature mustache, the trusted face of local news has taken his brand nationally, where he’s steadily risen through the NBC News ranks. In 2015, he replaced the beleaguered Brian Williams as the host of NBC Nightly News. And tonight he will broker the first televised debate between Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and his opponent, Democrat Hillary Clinton.

Though the seasoned journalist has long earned the public trust, there are two potential variables that leave me with some concern heading into tonight’s faceoff. The first is the debate prep “help” that Holt is receiving from Meet the Press moderator Chuck Todd. Though Meet the Press remains a Sunday morning Washington mainstay with high-profile guests and a rotating pundit panel, few are tuning in for Todd’s adroit interview skills. The guy has kid gloved Donald Trump in particular almost every step of the way. As Wonkette’s C.A. Pinkham wrote in February, “He is spectacularly bad at talking to humans, which is a problem when your entire job is talking to humans.”

Holt isn’t going to master the fine balance between equity and a quest for the truth by studying Todd. And Trump’s team has already taken great umbrage at the suggestion that fact checking should play a role in the debate. There’s a whole year and a half of established precedent – Trump running his mouth unchallenged by the media or moderators. As I’ve written angrily several times already, it’s key to his improbable campaign’s success.

So Team Trump’s unprecedented preconditions and some shaky moderator prep help from Chuckles the Toad leave room for skepticism. However as I’ve said, Holt has worked long and hard to reach this high-profile point in his career. He seems unlikely to disgrace himself a la NBC colleague Matt Lauer.

Positive examples have been admittedly hard to locate amongst the rubble that is mainstream media in the Trump era, but they do exist. If Lester Holt has followed the work of some of his cable news network colleagues, and endeavors to imitate their enforcement of bullshit-free zones, Americans might just get the quality presidential debate they deserve. Here are six unsung heroes regularly doing good work within a toxic 2016 media climate:

  • CNN Commentator Paul Begala is not afraid to tangle with other network personalities when they engage in inflammatory dissembling. Treat yourself to his tear down of New Day host Alisyn Camerota and the disgusting Corey Lewandowski on the subject of the supposed corruption of the Clinton Foundation. A highlight: “This is politics at its worst. This is a completely new standard, this is what the press and the Republicans do every time the Clintons run.”
  • There’s also a couple of lonely conservative commentators out there speaking the truth. One of them is Tara Setmayer, simply the best at calmly articulating conservative principles without losing her dignity or affronting the intelligence of open-minded liberals. Watch her rip former Pennsylvania Senator Rick a new Santorum over his sycophantic Trump support.
  • CNN’s Van Jones had me with his late-April burst of genuine emotion over the untimely death of rock god Prince. But he also coherently and accurately blasted Donald Trump’s farce of a Republican National Convention this summer, labeling it an evocation of a “Mad Max America.”
  • Continuing to respect the A-game of conservative pundits, Ana Navarro deserves recognition for her unfailing assertion that Donald Trump and his campaign team are exactly what they appear to be – a band of dangerous bigots. Who could reasonably argue with this logic? “You don’t get to make textbook racist remarks for a year and not be a racist. You don’t get to make textbook sexist remarks for a year and not be a misogynist.”
  • Tamron Hall of NBC/MSNBC is another Chicago media star who stepped up to the national stage after 10 years of work for a Fox affiliate. In addition to Hall’s obvious pulchritude, she’s become famous for calling out bullcrap when it stinks up her studio. Witness this beautiful takedown of Retired Rear Admiral Chuck Kubic after a pathetic attempt to whitewash Trump’s bullying of the Gold Star Khan family.
  • The all-star truth teller that is Joy Reid? I think her facial expression when speaking to Trump advocate Steve Cortes gets the message across. Cortes tried to tell Reid’s on-air panel, with a straight face, that the Donald runs “an incredibly non-racist campaign.” Umm hmm.

Bottom line: after Matt Lauer’s disastrous performance in last month’s candidate forum, the bar set for tonight’s debate is rather low. Given Lester Holt’s history and credentials, he’s poised to leap right over it – no matter what kind of coaching he’s received. But I hope he enters the studio and faces a live audience empowered by the sporadic, powerful forces of colleagues unafraid to challenge Trump’s singular brand of dissemination. The truth is out there.

Becky Sarwate is the current President of the Illinois Woman’s Press Association, founded in 1885, as well as Recording Secretary for the National Federation of Press Women. She is a national award-winning journalist, blogger, newsletter editor and theater critic. Becky lives in Chicago with her partner Bob and their menagerie of pets. Keep up with her at beckysarwate.com.
One Comment

Leave a Reply



  • Capegal
    26 September 2016 at 4:38 pm
  • advertisment
    Follow Us On Twitter